Welcome to East Side Bakery
At East Side Bakery, located at 122 Elm St in Cortland, NY, a passion for baked goods and local flavors creates a delightful experience. This hidden gem has quickly become a community favorite, renowned for its delectable pastries, artisanal breads, and mouthwatering Stromboli. Customers rave about the irresistible smoked pepperoni and the warm, inviting atmosphere crafted by the kind owners. With affordable prices and a wide variety of offerings, including pizza and homemade breakfast sausage, East Side Bakery is a must-visit for anyone seeking a sweet treat or a hearty meal. Your taste buds will thank you!
East Side Bakery: Reviews & Ratings
Hidden gem in Cortland . We loved it and highly recommend it! So much to choose from and everything we got was delicious!
The smoked pepperoni is excellent. The pastries and bread are also great. I can't comment on the pizza, but it looks good.
Everything here is delicious. Can't go wrong with a sweet treat or pizza and wings. I recently tried the medium Stromboli it was the size of half the pizza box and was amazing! The owners are so sweet and kind. Just remember cash or check when you go here!
I was so excited by the yummy food and cheap prices I forgot to take pictures! Definitely a spot to go for a treat! Everything smelled so good. We got an eclair, an apple turnover, a lemon cookie and a half moon. It's been a challenge not to devour it all in one sitting. I look forward to coming back to try their homemade breakfast sausage!
This is simply the BEST bakery I've been to in the US. They have a large selection of baked goods but also carry various meats and cheese and can do cakes and pizza to order. The best part about this place is the prices. $2 for a chocolate dipped almond horn (the best I've had since being Italy) is a STEAL! If you are jn town, you have to go. If your within an hr of this place, it's worth the drive!
Christine made the prettiest cupcakes for a co-worker who was retiring. She is so talented as well as everyone else who works there! Great small town family owned business. Highly recommend & everything they make is delicious :) Thanks again!
My sister took me here and I went all the time once a week to get her favs on pay day. Almond crescent cookies shaped into a half moon. Half and half cookies were mine. All the treats and even different pastas to buy was great. Nice place variety. Even the pizza
Best bakery in Central New York. Old school family owned Italian bakery...support local businesses! Slices are delicious and huge! Best Napoleon pastry I've ever had...always something new to try...I'm never disappointed and you won't be disappointed either. Friendly fast service.
I coordinated with the bakery to have a cake made for my gender reveal party. Christine was easy to communicate with and she made it very easy to arrange the cake, which was great because I live out of state and only made a trip to the area for the party. The cake turned out beautifully and was delicious. It was the center of my reveal party and I could not have asked for a better experience! Thank you!
Fresh sliced meats and cheese at crazy great prices? Wow!! Yes, yes and yes! I wanted to grab some fresh meat and cheese for sandwiches and my aunt suggested this place. I grabbed salami and provolone, freshly sliced on order. Then I grabbed a loaf of delicious italian bread and had them slice it for me also. It made for some great sandwhiches, small enough sized bread to not make full sandwiches but some great 4 or 5 bite sammies. Then we grabbed a few black and white cookies (at a great price also). Everything was delicious and they were the perfect solution to my hunger problem.
Location
-
122 Elm St Cortland, NY 13045 Hotline: (607) 756-4030
Welcome to the charming world of East Side Bakery, a delightful hidden gem nestled in the heart of Cortland, New York. Located at 122 Elm St, this unassuming bakery offers a veritable treasure trove of baked goods, savory treats, and sweet indulgences that promise to tantalize your taste buds.
East Side Bakery not only prides itself on an extensive menu but also on its inviting atmosphere. With options for takeout, street parking, and ample bike parking, it's an accessible spot for anyone craving homemade goodies. The warm and welcoming owners add a personal touch that makes every visit feel special. Just remember, they accept cash or check—something to keep in mind before you indulge!
Customers rave about the offerings here. Ann G. calls it a “hidden gem,” highlighting the diverse menu and the delicious fare. Whether you're in the mood for the smoked pepperoni or delectable pastries, each bite is a testament to East Side Bakery's commitment to quality and flavor. Emma C. was particularly impressed by the massive Stromboli, a generous size that left her wanting more. Such generous portions paired with a friendly atmosphere establish East Side Bakery as a must-visit location.
The aroma wafting through the bakery is intoxicating, with Jennifer D. noting her excitement to try everything from eclairs to apple turnovers. She highlights the thrill of not being able to resist tearing into their treats all at once! James C. takes it a step further, proclaiming it the best bakery he has experienced in the U.S.—and with prices like $2 for a chocolate-dipped almond horn, it’s clear this bakery is a steal.
Whether you're seeking a quick breakfast bite, a savory pizza, or simply craving a sweet treat, East Side Bakery has something for everyone. It's a community staple that promises not just food, but an experience that keeps you coming back for more. So take the time to visit East Side Bakery—it’s not just a destination; it’s a delicious adventure waiting to be had.
